Herisa Notebook Review

I can’t believe I bought this Herisa notebook on Amazon in July 2020 and am only now getting around to reviewing it! Such is life these days… but let’s take a long overdue look at this notebook.

herisa notebook front

I would guess that the Herisa notebook is kind of a generic item, perhaps marketed under a variety of brand names on Amazon. It seems to be a pretty typical practice for Chinese manufacturers to offer the same product under multiple brand names and see which one sells best. I’ve definitely seen other notebooks on Amazon that seem quite similar, though most of them seem to be available only in lined format. (See Vanpad, Aisbugur, ZZXT, Deziliao, Feela, LMTNNB, SULDAEFC, and many others.) I’ve also reviewed the very similar Taotree dot-grid notebook. But the Herisa came with unlined pages as an option, which is more rare.

herisa notebook top
herisa notebook review
herisa notebook back

The Herisa notebook has the typical Moleskine-clone characteristics: a black faux-leather cover, elastic closure, ribbon marker, expanding back pocket. It’s pleasantly chunky with a slightly padded cover that reminds me of the Pen & Ink sketchbook or the Scribe notebook I reviewed ages ago. The extras offered by the Herisa notebook are that you get a pen loop (which is quite solidly glued in, but possible to remove by sliding an Xacto knife in carefully on either side of it), a second ribbon marker, and a tuck pocket inside the front cover.

herisa notebook vs. moleskine
Herisa notebook on left, compared to older Moleskine
herisa vs moleskine
herisa vs moleskine thickness

There is no branding information anywhere on the notebook. The ribbon markers are brown, and there are matching head and foot bands, which as far as I can tell are just glued on for decoration rather than being part of the stitching of the signatures and spine. The construction of the notebook seems to be of good quality, with everything nice and square and even overhang on all sides. There is more cover overhang than I’d prefer, but it feels proportional to the rest of the notebook.

herisa notebook from amazon
herisa notebook flat opening
herisa notebook back pocket

Inside, there are a few lines for your contact details, but otherwise, it is totally plain. The notebook opens nice and flat due to a very flexible spine. The paper is a slightly creamy, smooth white. It is said to be 100 GSM, and does feel a bit heavier than average. And it performs quite well!

I tried all my usual pens and found the paper to be better than average for show-through, and had almost no bleed-through. A couple of inks feathered a bit in spots, but even when applying some pressure to flex nibs for line width variation, the paper was generally great. I did find that on another page, I got a few spots of bleeding if I cross-hatched a bit, and using layers of markers will start to loosen the paper fibers and cause some bleeding. I wouldn’t be confident enough in this paper to use it as a sketchbook with a lot of wet media, but for everyday journaling and notes, it should be fine for almost any user. I would just be prepared to try a few different fountain pens and inks to see which ones work.

fountain pen friendly herisa notebook
herisa notebook pen tests

Bottom line: I haven’t tested the Herisa notebook’s durability in long-term day to day use, but it seems solid enough to hold up well and I think I would buy this notebook again. I didn’t like the pen loop, but it turned out to be easier to remove than it was on the Taotree, and less damaging since there is no stitching going through the cover. There are other things about it that make it less than perfect in relation to my personal preferences, but the value overall makes the Herisa notebook a good choice.

As noted above, I bought this notebook a couple of years ago (with my own money, and I am not receiving any compensation for doing this review). I paid $10.99 for a two-pack, which for this level of quality is a great deal. I figured this price couldn’t possibly be available 2 years later, and when I searched “Herisa Notebook,” at first I didn’t even find this brand. But it’s actually still there, and still available... but not at the same price. It’s now even cheaper, at $9.99! But… and this is a big “but,” the description doesn’t say “100 GSM” anywhere. It says “Weight 150g” but I think they mean the actual weight of the whole notebook, not the paper weight. If the price went down, I would guess they had to reduce the paper quality. But at $9.99 for a two-pack, I think it’s worth a try to see. Recent reviews on Amazon seem to be positive. For those who prefer a larger size, Herisa also sells a lined 5×8″ notebook in blue with 130 GSM paper, currently $6.99 for a two-pack! A black, pocket-sized lined version is also available, but they are much more expensive, at least right now.

Other inexpensive notebooks in my Amazon store.

Michael Lindsay-Hogg’s Diaries

I spotted the image below in a recent New York Times article about Michael Lindsay-Hogg, the filmmaker who directed the Beatles documentary “Let It Be.”

The diaries described as follows in the article:

He has preserved much of what he went through with the Beatles in diaries, which he has kept since the “Ready Steady Go!” years.

He led me to a bookcase in the memento-filled library next to his art studio. It was filled with dusty leather-bound diaries, many overstuffed with letters and photos. At my suggestion, he dug out the volume from 1969. It was curiously slender.

He thumbed through the pages and landed on January 30, the blustery day in London when the Beatles played in public for the last time. As captured by Mr. Lindsay-Hogg and his team, their swan-song performance was the climax of both “Let It Be” and “Get Back.”

The diary page was blank, except for one word scribbled in black ballpoint pen.

Roof.

“The busier you are,” Mr. Lindsay-Hogg said, “the less you write down.”

I’m sure there’s a lot of other interesting material in those diaries! They look to be bound in an interesting way, as if they are designed to be more of a scrapbook or album, with extra room for stuff to be pasted in. But Mr. Lindsay-Hogg seems to have used up all that room and more! Those diaries look super-stuffed!

Jimbo Blachly’s Notebooks

I happened to notice an Instagram post from Printed Matter about a facsimile book of artist Jimbo Blachly’s notebooks. (Available on the Printed Matter website.)

The activity of drawing is primary to Jimbo Blachly’s work. In addition to individual drawings and watercolors, he has kept daily notebooks and sketchbooks which make up a large visual diary going back decades. Blachly states: “The responsiveness of line and mark making to the fluidity of thought. The economy of means-ink and reed pen or pencil and the compact portability of small notebooks means I am almost never without the ability to draw or make a quick notation in my day-to-day life. Drawing for me is a mirror, reflecting the relationship between the perceiving mind, the hand and the myriad phenomena be it oak leaves, mosquitoes, memories or burning forests ”

–Jimbo Blachly statement, jimboblachly.com

Blachly has been keeping 3.5 x 5.5″ notebooks for years, according to his website. I was sorry to see that the facsimile book is slightly larger, so not really a true facsimile. I still might have to buy a copy. I like the look of the drawings– interesting colors, abstract but sort of based on cityscapes and landscapes.

I’d love to see some of Jimbo Blachly’s notebooks in person. Unfortunately it looks like he cut up some of the sketchbooks to exhibit the drawings and sell them separately. I guess an artist has to do what he’s gotta do, but that always makes me sad!

Truffaut’s Notebooks

I took screenshots of these wonderful notebook images about a month ago. I think they are from a book about the French film director François Truffaut, but I somehow managed to lose track of the link back to the page where I found the images. If anyone recognizes the pages, please let me know so I can properly credit the original source!

In the meantime, while searching around for online images of Truffaut’s notebooks, I also came across the image below, from a blog called Mon Cahier du Cinéma à Moi. It’s apparently a childhood notebook of Truffaut’s, with the comment below saying that the young Truffaut preferred to spend time sitting in a movie theater seat rather than on a school bench.

(© Romain Duchez / Mon cahier du cinéma à moi)

I’d love to see more of Truffaut’s notebooks!

Tsubame Fools Notebook Review

Several years ago, I linked to an article about the history of an iconic Japanese notebook: The Tsubame Fools Notebook. It’s taken me a while, but I’ve finally managed to buy and review one!

tsubame fools notebook japanese notebook

I don’t know what took me so long. They’re not that hard to find, and they certainly aren’t expensive. This notebook only cost me $3.00 at Yoseka Stationery‘s lovely store in Greenpoint.

I love the design, which looks classic and timeless. The format is a typical single signature exercise book, with a taped spine. I notice that the spine tape wraps further around on the front than on the back– it’s deliberate, but I wonder why?

tsubame fools notebook back cover
tsubame fools notebook inside

On the inside front cover, there is some text, all in Japanese. Then you get to the lovely bright paper. It’s lined with dots that can be used to guide vertical lines.

The paper works well with all fountain pens. Even flexing nibs with significant pressure produced no problems. Only the Accu-liner and Super Sharpie bled.

tsubame fools notebook pen tests
tsubame fools notebook back of page pen test

What’s not to love? It’s a nice looking $3.00 notebook that performs extremely well. I could only wish that they made a 3.5 x 5.5″ version with unlined paper!

Bob Dylan’s Notebook

In this past weekend’s New York Times there is an article about the new Bob Dylan Center in Tulsa, OK, where all his archives are stored.

The collection includes a variety of artifacts, including Bob Dylan’s notebook shown below, in which he made notes for lyrics, many of which evolved into the final version known in his songs.

bob dylan's notebook at bob dylan center archive

Woody Guthrie’s Notebooks

I recently went to the Morgan Library in New York City, primarily to see the Holbein exhibition that’s currently being shown there. (Well worth seeing and it closes soon, so go if you can!) The Morgan is also currently showing an exhibition about Woody Guthrie, which happens to feature quite a few notebooks!

This composition book was the first thing that caught my eye. It was mounted in case next to one of Guthrie’s Gibson guitars.

Here’s a couple more, including a spiral notebook with one of Guthrie’s comic sketches, and an address book from the 1940s, open to a page listing the blues musician Lead Belly and Alan Lomax, who is known for recording, archiving, and popularizing American folk music.

A daily diary in which Guthrie wrote to his unborn daughter:

A spiral notebook recording things said by Guthrie’s daughter Cathy at the age of 4. Sadly, Cathy died in a fire later than year.

Another daily diary in a larger format, in which Guthrie mused about love and sex:

There were lots of other interesting artifacts in the exhibit. I had seen images of some of Woody Guthrie’s notes and sketches before but had no idea he was such a prolific notebook-keeper!

Notebook Addict of the Week: chamo_san

This week’s addict is chamo_san, an artist from Barcelona who I’ve been following on Instagram. A lot of the work he shares is done in sketchbooks, and they all look rather lovely piled up like this!

The work he’s creating inside them is quite stunning too! Here’s just a sampling:

You can see more here: @chamo_san

Weird, Ugly Moleskine Planner

I was browsing eBay recently and came across a very odd Moleskine planner. I searched for it on Moleskine’s own site but found nothing. The only other listing I found was at Target:

Digging still further, I found another Target listing for a beige version, which was also listed on the website of Sandman Books.

This is so weird. To be honest, I thought at first that it was someone’s idea of a joke to Photoshop together a really stupid looking fake Moleskine product (which I am not above doing myself). But Target actually shows this product as being in stock in one of their stores, so I guess it’s real.

The product description says the covers are made with special paper (and yes, the typo is in the original):

FAVINI PAPER – SUSTAINABILIY AND INNOVATION
Made in Italy: the planner’s covers are made from innovative Crush and Remake paper by Favini. Based in northern Italy and tracing its history to 1736, Favini is a leading global producer of natural, fiber-based materials. Remake is made using up-cycled leather residues, while Crush is produced using residues from organic products.

I suppose I could imagine something uglier if I tried, but I don’t want to. The whole concept looks like a patchwork of features from other journals you’d find in Target, or a Hallmark store or the checkout lane at HomeGoods. Gold modern calligraphy? With a ring binding that looks like it’s made of cork? These things aren’t ugly per se, but it’s like they’ve been patched in from a different design universe, and the way this all comes together with Moleskine’s branding looks terrible, at least in my opinion.

Moleskine used to have a very particular brand identity and aesthetic, but they seem to be going far astray.

Banned Blank Books!

Shocking news from a publishing industry newsletter:

Sen. Ted Cruz Slams Blank Book Sales for ‘Potentially Offensive Content’

Sen. Ted Cruz (R.-Tex.) took his crusade against books he deems objectionable to a new level this week when he warned against the dangers of selling diaries, journals and other blank books to minors.

Just days after ranting about the threat posed by anti-racist literature at Supreme Court nominee Ketanji Brown Jackson’s Senate confirmation hearing, Cruz turned his attention to the potential hazards inherent in blank books sold by retailers nationwide, from bookshops and stationery stores to big-box retailers like Walmart.

In a speech to constituents, Cruz said, “What many people don’t know is that absolutely anything could be written in those pages. We must protect our kids from their own thoughts.” To drive his point home, Cruz displayed a stack of personal diaries that his staff had discovered in their own children’s possession.

A spokesperson for the National Stationery Association commented: “Senator Cruz’s words speak for themselves. As has happened with other books and related items he’s criticized in the past, dramatically increased sales will be the result. We wholeheartedly support that outcome.” —Robert Gray

From Shelf Awareness

I loved it so much I had to repost the whole thing! Happy April Fools Day everyone!

Notebooks, journals, sketchbooks, diaries: in search of the perfect page…