Are “Smart Notebooks” Smart Enough?

I keep reading about the Rocketbook Everlast, including in this recent review:

“But what if you could combine the best of old-school notebooks with modern tech? That’s the ambition behind Rocketbook’s new Everlast notebook. You use it in the normal offline way, but when you scan the pages with your phone it shoots everything automatically to your preferred cloud service and makes it, in theory, more integrated with all your data. And it is infinitely erasable and reusable. I decided to test it around town and at the local hipster café. Would it replace my trusty Moleskines?”

Rocketbook’s Everlast promises to combine modern tech with old-school pen and paper. Will it pass Steven Poole’s chicken test?

Read more at : This “smart” notebook must try harder | 1843

I am somewhat intrigued by this concept for a business setting, where it might be handy to have a lot of notes backed up to digital files. Or for list making, maybe, when you want to have things on your phone. But it just seems like a nuisance to have to photograph every page to upload it. I like the Livescribe concept better– using a special pen with the Livescribe notebook means your writings are automatically saved, without having to take a photo. Their notebooks are also nicer looking than the spiral-bound Rocketbook. Even though Rocketbook has a 3.5 x 5.5″ pocket size, I can’t see myself using one. If you’ve tried the Rocketbook or Livescribe, let us know in the comments what you think of it!

What I’m Using Now: October 2018

My last update was in May 2018, when I shocked everyone by not having any Moleskine notebook in my daily carry. Let’s see how things have changed since then!

I am still using the Leda Sketchbook shown in the May 2018 post. I’m almost done with it and am planning to replace it with a Bindewerk Linen journal with plain pages. The Leda was great for sketching and held up very well — I used it a lot for a couple of months when I was drawing every day, and then still kept it in my bag even when I was not drawing as much. The Bindewerk will be interesting to try for sketching. The paper is quite different and a bit more refined than what I usually use for sketching. If it doesn’t seem conducive to drawing, I may switch back to a Moleskine sketchbook and save the Bindewerk notebooks for journaling.

I am still using my beloved Nolty 2018 diary and am excited to be upgrading to the leather covered Nolty Gold for 2019. Full review to come. (I bought it via Rakuten, which had a better price than Kinokuniya’s online store. I haven’t seen 2019 Nolty diaries in the NYC store at all.)

For my journal and catch-all notebook, I went from the Bindewerk dotted notebook I was using in May back to a squared Moleskine, which I finished recently. I then did something unusual. Instead of starting a fresh notebook, I re-purposed a Moleskine with plain pages that I’d had on my desk for the last couple of years. I started it as a doodle notebook– I used to spend a lot of time on telephone calls for work and would be doodling constantly. I decided to try to channel those doodles into a single notebook rather than messing up all my work papers. I generated a few pages of dense doodles but then didn’t keep up the habit, mainly since my work changed and I wasn’t on long calls anymore. I then used some pages for handwriting practice with fountain pens, using only one side of each page since the Moleskine paper, as we know, tends to bleed. This all left me with a notebook about 1/4 used and it seemed silly to just leave it that way, so I started using it for my diary entries, lists and other jottings.

Other notebooks in regular use that aren’t daily carries:

An old Moleskine Volant used for French class notes. I’m almost done with this one and am not sure what I’ll replace it with. I’ve always used slim notebooks for my class notes, and right now, all my slim notebooks are either buried in a storage unit, or in my to-be-reviewed pile. I guess I’d better get cracking on some reviews, or I’ll have to write my French vocab elsewhere!

A Michael Roger Decomposition Book  This has become my catch-all for notes and sketches relating to a home renovation project. A very complicated home renovation project. That is going to take months. And cost a ton of money. This notebook contains a lot of angst!

I also still have a couple of other notebooks that get occasional use: a Pentalic  watercolor sketchbook, an old Hobonichi Techo for handwriting practice, and a white Conceptum  notebook with some notes and lists relating to this past year’s move and renovation plans.

And I have so many other notebooks waiting in the wings to be used! At least two or three things in my to-be-reviewed pile seem like they could have daily usage potential, including a couple of unusual Asian brands. Stay tuned for reviews over the next couple of months!

Other People’s Pages: Notebook Links

I see so many interesting notebook stories on other blogs and yet I never get around to doing a link round-up on this site! Trying to get better about that… so here are a few things that caught my eye recently:

The Gentleman Stationer reviews a new brand of notebooks called  Kunisawa:

“…a new venture launched in 2017 by Kawachiya, an older, established Japanese paper manufacturer. Kunisawa is to be marketed as a “prestigious stationery brand for business performers,” and they’ve clearly focused on making a clean, fairly minimal notebook that doesn’t look out of place in an office or a boardroom.”

Read more at Notebook Review: Kunisawa Find Notebooks

 

At The Pen Addict, Sarah Read reviews the Illo Sketchbook:

“I could tell as soon as I opened the packaging that the illo Sketchbook was pretty snazzy. Far too snazzy for my poor art skills. Fortunately, I live with a talented artist who was willing to put this book through thorough tests.”

Read more at Illo Sketchbook Review

 

The Gadgeteer reviews some starry notebooks from Levenger:

“These beautiful notebooks have celestial-themed covers, which would make them a perfect gift for the astronomer in your life.”

Read more at Levenger has some “heavenly” notebooks for journal keeping

 

The Well-Appointed Desk reviews a lovely pair of Elemental Notebooks:

“Back when the Elemental Notebooks Kickstarter launched, I was all in. I love me a good themed notebook, and I find anything geeky endearing. I was very impressed by all the thoughtful design features that Laurie & Greg had put into the notebooks. From the title page to the colored paper edges it looked like an excellent design.”

Read more at Notebook Review: Elemental Notebooks

Review: Superior Maker Notebook

superior maker notebook review - 1

This notebook was a random Amazon find. I’d never heard of the brand Superior Maker and figured it was some Chinese manufacturer marketing cheap knock-off notebooks directly. Their products, which also include lint rollers and rubber doorstops, are indeed made in China, but the company is actually based in New Zealand. Other than that, there isn’t much information about them. There is definitely no romantic backstory about Hemingway or Picasso or anyone using this brand, but let’s take a look their notebook, which is actually rather nice!

superior maker notebook review - 3superior maker notebook review - 2superior maker notebook review - 4

The first impression I had was that the Superior Maker notebook is pleasingly chunky– it’s a bit thicker than most pocket notebooks, with somewhat thicker covers under a softer textured faux leather. It is 3.5 x 5.5″ and is just a hair smaller in length and width than a pocket Moleskine (shown below for comparison). The cover overhang is bigger than I’d like, but I found myself a little less bothered by it because it seems proportional to the thickness of the boards, and it is squarely bound and even all around.

superior maker notebook review - 5superior maker notebook review - 10superior maker notebook review - 11

The packaging is very standard– paper wrapper under the shrinkwrap, brand stamped on the back, elastic closure, ribbon marker. On the inside, it is totally plain. There is a pocket in the back. When you open the notebook, there is a sheet of stickers tucked inside the front cover, which is a nice extra. One label is meant to be used on the front cover, and the others are page tabs. The pages are lined in a nice faint grey.

superior maker notebook review stickers - 1

superior maker notebook review - 7superior maker notebook review - 9superior maker notebook review - 8

The lines are a bit wider spaced than most notebooks, at 7mm vs. 6mm in a Moleskine. The paper doesn’t feel quite as smooth as Moleskine paper, but has a similar creamy tone. It is said to be 100 GSM and does feel heavier than standard Moleskine paper. Show-through is about average but bleed-through was a bit better than average. There were a few wetter pens that showed slight feathering but otherwise it is actually pretty fountain pen friendly unless you are using a wider, wetter nib or pressing down to get a lot of flex in your line width. I even tested some watercolors and found that the paper held up fine, though I would not recommend heavy wet usage.

superior maker notebook pen tests - 2superior maker notebook pen tests - 3superior maker notebook pen tests - 1

Overall, this is a cute little notebook that turned out to be a very pleasant surprise in terms of quality and value. If it came with blank or grid pages, and had a little less overhang, I’d consider it pretty much perfect! It is only $8.95 on Amazon! The 5 x 8.25″ version is only $9.95. They also have some 3 packs of Field Notes-ish journals, and a heavier weight sketchbook, and everything qualifies for free shipping if you meet Amazon’s $25 minimum or have a Prime membership. The Superior Maker notebook is definitely worth checking out.

The Campus Sketcher

Nice to see an urban sketcher documenting life at the University of Washington. Eli Pasco has a regular feature on the campus newspaper’s website:

I have been urban sketching for almost two years now, and have grown both as a person and an artist. I have developed my style, perfected my technique, and exposed myself to events, people, and communities beyond my horizons. Urban sketching has made me an explorer in my own home, allowing me to approach every commute, interaction, and experience with open eyes. Early morning and late night commutes on the bus become impromptu people drawing sessions, lampposts become a fascinating study, and a university campus becomes a treasure trove for sketching everything from people on the go to a wide range of architectural styles.

Read more at: A new year means a new sketchbook | Features | dailyuw.com

Review: Seawhite Travel Journal

Seawhite of Brighton is a British brand of art supplies targeted at the educational market. I’ve only seen their products in stores once, when I was in London. But I did find this sketchbook available on Amazon, and decided to give it a try..

seawhite sketchbook - 1

As noted in my post Size Matters: When A6 Isn’t A6, this is claimed to be an A6 notebook, but is actually slightly larger, at 109 x 153mm. Otherwise, the initial impression is very Moleskine-like. The color and design of the paper band almost gets into trademark-violation territory in terms of its similarity to Moleskine’s design, or older versions of it, anyway. The cover is the usual black faux-leather texture, although the cover boards are narrower so there is a groove next to the spine. The cover overhang is bigger than I would like, and it is not even all the way around. One of the corners is wrapped a bit sloppily. The other thing that made me wonder about quality control is that there were some reddish smudges on the page edges, as if it had been handled by someone with dirty hands. I’m pretty sure this was there before I took off the shrinkwrap and wasn’t from my own hands. The back cover also had some minor scuffs.

seawhite sketchbook - 4seawhite sketchbook - 2seawhite sketchbook - 3seawhite sketchbook - 11

The Seawhite sketchbook is shown next to a pocket size Moleskine in the comparison shots below:

seawhite sketchbook - 8seawhite sketchbook - 9seawhite sketchbook - 10

The brand is stamped on the back cover, there is an elastic closure and a ribbon marker (in a fun lime green), and there is a pocket inside the back cover. But oddly, the pocket is not the full size of the notebook! It’s like they bought pockets that were made for standard 3.5 x 5.5″ notebooks rather than having them made for this less typical size.

seawhite sketchbook - 7seawhite sketchbook - 6

The notebook opens very flat. There is no branding on the inside of the notebook– just 128 pages of somewhat toothy 130 gsm paper. The paper seems quite sturdy. The fibers in it caused a few little bits of feathering with wet pens, but it otherwise performed quite well, with better than average show-through, and almost no bleed. The paper also seemed to hold up to watercolors and markers without buckling or fibers pulling away. I wouldn’t use it for a lot of wet painting, but it should be fine if you just want to add some touches of color to sketches. This paper seems similar in texture and weight to the Handbook Artist Journals I’ve used, but it is a brighter, cooler off-white.

seawhite sketchbook pen tests - 3seawhite sketchbook pen tests - 4seawhite sketchbook pen tests - 1seawhite sketchbook pen tests - 2

If you find a standard 3.5 x 5.5″ pocket sketchbook a bit cramped, this size may be a nice way to get a bit more elbow room while still fitting in most pockets. The exterior construction may not be as refined as some other hardcover sketchbooks, but it seems solid enough. You can get this size on Amazon for $11.28, which is reasonable, though that is from a 3rd party seller who charges $4.90 in shipping. I bought mine directly from Amazon and paid $9.95 but they don’t seem to have this size/format right now. They do have other formats available, including a landscape A6 version, and other A5 and A4 sketchbooks and lined journals, as well as watercolor sketchbooks. The prices seem reasonable: about $23 for an A4 size watercolor sketchbook, compared to $28 for a comparable Moleskine. This may not be a high-end sketchbook for professional artists, but given that Seawhite is aimed at the student market, it should be a good option for many users.

Behind the Scenes at the Hilroy Notebook Factory

Hilroy is a well-known notebook brand in Canada. (I’ve never tried one, but some of our notebook addicts have!) Click through to an article with some cool video from the factory where their products are made! I’d love to visit a notebook factory someday…

Hilroy’s notebooks have been a mainstay of Canadian schoolchildren for years, but can the company survive the digital generation?

Read more: Back to school special: How the iconic Hilroy notebook gets made – The Globe and Mail

Tenth Anniversary Giveaway Winners

Here are the 10 winners of my 10th anniversary giveaway:

From post comments:

Joe Roosevans (2018/09/15 at 5:40 am)

Charles (2018/09/12 at 4:36 pm)

Eileen (2018/09/12 at 9:03 am)

Via Twitter:

Lady Temeraire (@ladytemeraire)

Sam Mauck (@samrmauck)

Via Instagram:

Carrie Bond (bond_carrie)

Helen (Helenmelon27)

Rosie (Pinky.punky.ink)

Via Facebook:

Jean Marmo

Michael Elson

If you are a winner, please send me your mailing address ASAP via DM in Twitter or Facebook or contact form on this site! Thank you everyone!

Moleskine Project Exhibition

I didn’t realize this Moleskine Project exhibition was an annual event in NYC. This year’s exhibition is already over, but it’s always nice to see some beautiful art on notebook pages!

This one is by Vanessa Foley:

And this one is by Greg Gandy:

 

See lots more at: Annual Moleskine Project Exhibition Move to New York City

“Empowering” Notebooks for Women

Here’s an interesting take on a particular segment of the notebook and journal market:

I love buying useless little journals and covering my desk with piles of colorful sticky notes. Fall and its corresponding school-and-office-supply bonanzas are a sign of a fresh start: I love telling myself that these journals and sticky notes will make me more organized and therefore more productive and therefore better at my job and therefore happier. Is it true? Not exactly. Does it matter? Not at all.

There’s just one small problem: So many of the office supplies that are marketed toward women are incredibly condescending.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by ban.do (@shopbando) on

I’m not a big fan of “notebooks for women” or things with slogans on them in general, and let’s face it, a notebook that says “#girlboss” is not going to counter discrimination in the workplace and help more women become CEOs. Do feminist slogans on notebooks trivialize the issues women face, or are they a fun and encouraging way to feel motivated? What do you think?

Read more: The case against “empowering” office supplies – Vox

Notebooks, journals, sketchbooks, diaries: in search of the perfect page…